"KISS should NOT be in the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame"-Dave Marsh

That 70s Guy

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Jan 21, 2010
Posts
16,512
Reaction score
6,495
Location
Nova Scotia Canada
DAVE MARSH BREAKS SILENCE - KISS Should NOT Be In The HOF!
Dave Marsh's Updated Thoughts on KISS & Their Rock Hall Induction
In case you think Dave Marsh has mellowed over the years regarding KISS, think again. The article below is taken from his Rock & Rap Confidential newsletter, which was released today. Not all the artists listed at the end of the article were picked by Marsh.

Marsh on KISS (2014):

WHY KISS AIN’T ON OUR LIST... Dave Marsh writes: In the fall of 1973, recently arrived in New York City and besotted by the extraordinary shows I’d seen by the New York Dolls in Queens and downtown Manhattan, I decided I wanted to investigate who the city’s best bands other than the Dolls might be. This wound up being a story that ran first in Newsday, the Long Island daily where I had the pop music beat; then Creem, which I was no longer editing but still writing for; and finally the British weekly, Melody Maker.

The article, which may have been headlined Great White Rock in its first appearance, boasted that there were currently a dozen “excellent” rock acts in the New York City area, and talked about eight of those I had seen. In order of appearance they were: The Dynomiters, Harlots of 42nd Street, Kiss, Luger, Elliott Murphy’s Aqua Show, New York Central, Queen Elizabeth featuring Wayne County and Teenage Lust. (I can’t remember why I didn’t mention the Miamis. I loved the Miamis—on stage anyway, like so many of these bands, that group was never captured right on tape.)

Coming up with a punk icon (Wayne County), one of the key New York singer-songwriters of the period whose career has lasted forty years (Elliott Murphy), and a huge pop success in the space of 2,500 words isn’t bad. But history—helped along by Wikipedia which at least three people have tried to amend for accuracy, all rejected by the mysterian Wikiprocess—remembers none of this. If it did, the Kiss Army might salute me rather than flooding my website with what amounts to “nyah, nyah, nyah,” now that Kiss is finally going to get into the Hall of Fame.

Because that article was the first mention of Kiss in the press, and it was not hostile. In its entirety it reads:

“This group looks as if it just stepped out of the underground movie Pink Flamingos, leading me to believe that I was right all along in thinking that the glitter craze was an ugliness contest.

“But Kiss's music sounds as if it is the most thought-out, controlled sound around, and the stage show is just as professional. And, they say, Eddie Kramer (of Led Zeppelin and Electric Ladyland) wants to produce them. Heavy metal meets El Topo.”

OK, I called them ugly. Why the **** did you think they added the face paint? Other than that, it’s at least a kind of backhanded praise. It’s honest, too. I didn’t like Kiss, but I recognized what they had going for them (though I wish I had mentioned manager Bill Aucoin, a great market manipulator who’s been cheated out of almost all credit thanks to the megalomania infesting that band’s camp.)

Musically, I was done with them before I ever turned the first album over to the second side. Kiss had an extraordinary aptitude for adopting every cliché in hard rock history, and a complete absence of any ability to create so much as a hint of a new one. (I suppose maybe they were the model for Motley Crue?) The most interesting of their studio albums is Destroyer, and it’s not all that interesting, except as an example of the highly professional output of producer Bob Ezrin and guitarist Dick Wagner during the mid-‘70s. On their own, they were not clever at coming up with riffs, the beats are as repetitious as punk but without the energy, and their most interesting lyric is “Beth” which is nothing more than third-rate Bob Seger blended with second-rate Billy Joel, or maybe “Detroit Rock City” which is a clumsy J. Geils swipe...and so forth except for the disco album, I guess.

But they have the best make-up in the Hall. Until Insane Clown Posse is inducted, at least.

I realize this paints Kiss as more mediocre than incompetent, but....well, if the only qualification is having made a record at least 25 years before the ballots got mailed out, they are qualified, and perhaps I shall be fortunate enough not to live to see the advent of Justin Bieber and One Day in the Hall's once formidable list of inductees.

And yeah, Kiss inspired a lot of kids to want to be in bands. So did half a dozen girls (and boys!) in every high school graduating class.

All that mediocrity was harmless enough until the boastful bassist decided to turn it into a propaganda machine for the only two things he’s ever loved: Gene Simmons and money. Sex Money Kiss, his book on how to become a rich success, offers a stupendous (or maybe I mean stupefying) blend of preposterous career advice, dangerously over-simplified and inaccurate economic information and advice, and an account of human intercourse—by which I don’t mean just sex--that verifies emotional stagnation at the age of maybe fourteen. You could figure the same stuff out in maybe fifteen minutes of watching his dumb-ass TV show. (Yes, this means I passed on reading the other two. Pointless repetition is one of the worst things about Kiss.)

Alas, Simmons also has politics, of a sort, though I’d sure he would deny anything of the kind because that might alienate part of the audience—although since he views the rest of the species as essentially a chain of ATMs, maybe not. He is basically a cheerleader for capitalism and spreading the U.S. system abroad in ways that make Bono look like John Maynard Keynes.

Then there are his sexual politics, which amount to “Bend over, meat” and I mean that literally. It is true that Simmons imagines all other human beings (except his sainted mama and perhaps his kids) as inherently inferior to himself, but he has a particular contempt for women. I stopped being amused by this along about the time that he began to boast about his Polaroid collection. The misogynist misanthropy reaches a pinnacle in his 2008 book, Ladies of the Night: A Historical and Personal Perspective on the Oldest Profession in the World.

It seems odd that he didn’t write the book he’s best qualified for on this topic, which would be a history of pimping. Because if Simmons isn’t an evangelist he is certainly a peddler, and he practices the hard sell and the emotional con. Kiss didn’t have fans, it had an Army because they were the biggest band of their era. The truth is, Kiss never sold more than 2 million copies of a studio album although that was precisely the time when the Bee Gees and Fleetwood Mac, the Eagles and a bunch of others began to sell 10 million (and more). One reason Kiss’s audience is early teenagers-- though these days that is true more often emotionally than chronologically, of course—is that only someone stuck there would be so militantly gullible.

Why shouldn’t Kiss be in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame? Because they have added not the slightest musical value to rock, which is why they were not especially huge record sellers. And because, so far, in one way or another, the Hall has avoided honoring the music at its most mercantile and shallow.

But above all because there are so many worthy candidates who are not in the Hall of Fame. At the snail ‘s pace at which the Hall parcels out induction, many of the artists in the list below will be dead before they are even on the ballot. In Kiss’s own genre and time, by which I mean 1970s hard rock, almost every fan of it as a whole (as opposed to the Kiss Army) would agree that at least Cheap Trick, Deep Purple, Judas Priest and Motorhead are not just more deserving, but far, far better choices. Not every one of these fifty artists, who operated at more or less the same time as Kiss, are going to end up in the Hall of Fame nor should they. But they’re all better than Kiss.

Alice in Chains
Anthrax
Bad Brains
Bad Company
Black Oak Arkansas
Black Crowes
Blue Oyster Cult
Body Count
Bootsy’s Rubber Band
Canned Heat
Cheap Trick
The Commodores
Deep Purple
Def Leppard
Dio
Foreigner
Free
J. Geils Band
Humble Pie
Iron Maiden
The James Gang
Rick James
Joan Jett and the Blackhearts
Judas Priest
Krokus
Living Colour
MC5
Molly Hatchet
Mother’s Finest
Motorhead
Mott the Hoople
Mudhoney
New York Dolls
Ted Nugent / Amboy Dukes
Ohio Players
Pantera
Poison
Procol Harum
The Scorpions
Sepultura
Social Distortion
Soundgarden
Steppenwolf
Twisted Sister
Ten Years After
Thin Lizzy
The Time
War
W.A.S.P.
White Zombie

(This list was compiled by RRC, not Dave Marsh alone.)

http://tomlanesblog.blogspot.com/2014/0 ... s.html?m=1
 

LG

Fade To Black
Joined
Apr 20, 2009
Posts
36,862
Reaction score
73
Seems like Marsh has an agenda, he makes some good points but this is a big league assassination of KISS plain and simple.

I think Simmons & Company will have a response to this and no matter what they are in the HOF now.(Even though I couldn't care less about this particular institution and their quirks)
 

Pappy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2013
Posts
140
Reaction score
0
Even if all those bands were better than Kiss. Kiss is more FAMOUS than all of them. Whether you like Kiss or not you absolutely can not argue against how big they are. How silly
 

foreverblue

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2009
Posts
472
Reaction score
4
Location
melbourne australia
Even if all those bands were better than Kiss. Kiss is more FAMOUS than all of them. Whether you like Kiss or not you absolutely can not argue against how big they are. How silly

kiss is bigger than deep purple?

i like some of their music, and i'm talking 1975 -81, not this flogging a dead horse for $$ that they do now. but to be honest they were a novelty band that played hard rock and became extremely popular.
the guy hit the nail on the head in regars to simmons though.
 

mrJim

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2013
Posts
841
Reaction score
5
Location
South Carolina
A couple quotes I thought were right on the money and funny to boot.

"he views the rest of the species as essentially a chain of ATMs," that is so Simmons

and this is just funny:
"But they have the best make-up in the Hall. Until Insane Clown Posse is inducted, at least."

He is pretty serious about this topic though. Way more serious than I could ever be of them
 

METALPRIEST

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2009
Posts
33,603
Reaction score
67
Location
U.S.A.
This really does get old doesn't it?? :oyea:

They're in the hall of fame....deal with it :wank:
 

Khor1255

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2011
Posts
2,967
Reaction score
68
Who is Dave Marsh and why should anyone care what he thinks?
 

Magic

Woman of the World
Staff member
Administrator
Joined
Apr 20, 2009
Posts
24,962
Reaction score
4,757
Location
Ohio, USA
Who is Dave Marsh and why should anyone care what he thinks?

Dave Marsh is a committee member of the RRHOF, music critic, writer, and talk show host. He use to be the editor of Cream Magazine and writes for Rolling Stone.

I would say he is qualified to make critical judgements of KISS. Although his comments do come off sounding like he holds a grudge.
 

Khor1255

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2011
Posts
2,967
Reaction score
68
Cream magazine (the one that regularly dismissed all but the most mainstream bands) and Rolling Stone (a left wing rag that has almost zero to do with music unless it happens to carry a message they already endorse)?

You'll forgive me if I question his qualifications as an unbiased music critic. The fact that he even mentions Simmons' politics shows you exactly where his priorities are (hint: not music).

Most of the musicians I really like I am completely on the other side of the social/political spectrum from. That doesn't keep me from giving credit where it is due.
 

Find member

Forum statistics

Threads
30,706
Posts
1,067,726
Members
6,366
Latest member
Dustybroom

Staff online

Members online

Top