Zeppelin II or IV

[stepcousin]

it a tough one. Maybe start to finish, I'd go with II. IV has some tremendous songs but a couple of 'em kinda slow the pace a bit.

 

[Paperlink133]

Zeppelin II
I love some songs in IV though, but I've never been a fan of Zeppelin songs which has a fantasy theme, so I went for II. I even like I more than IV...!

I know, I know that Ramble On is influenced by LOTR too, by I like it more than The Battle of Evermore or Misty Mountain Hop!

 

[wormwood]

For some reason I find IV to be a more complete record. II was good, but IV opened up the formula a bit more I think. Stronger closing song too. When the Levee Breaks is amazing!

 

[Slip'nn2Darkness]

II..


Because I was alive when I witnessed all the souls that were saved by this album..

 

[Hydrazoic Acid]

Led Zeppelin IV

 

[Mr. Bob Dobolina]

Another toughie but I went with II.

 

[gcczep]

II+II=

This...

 

[Lynch]

I am pleasantly surprised to see II in the lead here!

 

[gcczep]

II has a more harder, bluesier fell while the fourth has the band doing a more refined statement of Page's "light and shade" vision of the acoustic/electric elements of music.

 

[ILoveJimmyPage]

II has a more harder, bluesier fell while the fourth has the band doing a more refined statement of Page's "light and shade" vision of the acoustic/electric elements of music.

I couldn't have said it better myself. Also, IV has always had more depth to me. II is just fun to listen to, though one of my top Zep tunes (Ramble On) is on that one.

I'd listen to IV over the Brown Bomber anyday.