ILJP, yes, though I still think AI is basically garbage, like all reality TV, but I watch it now because Tyler is so entertaining, and I agree with most of what you say there. Though J-Lo is one of my all time musical guilty-pleasures, at first I confess it was mostly an infatuation with her rear-end!...but the more you get to listen to her she has superb analysis of singers and performance, and she's very witty, and seems a sweet person, and I always had a soft spot for her records as my wife is a huge fan of hers, so I couldn't have avoided her music over the years even if I had wanted to!! Randy Jackson is the one on the show who I totally don't get, all I can find out about him pre-American Idol that particularly impresses me, is that he was a session musician and he apparently once played bass with Springsteen, the Blue Oyster Cult, and Whitesnake, but his sole contribution to AI seems to be the obligatory "Good job dawg" to almost every contestant.