Brown Eyed Girl vs Cinnamon Girl

[Metal Health]

Brown Eyed Girl

 

[Speed King]

Like both, voted Cinnamon Girl

 

[Lynch]

Not very often that I'll vote for Neil in ANY poll, but I can't stand Brown Eyed Girl. Cinnamon Girl is ok to hear every so often.

 

[Jonny Come Lately]

Cinnamon Girl gets my vote - it's the original Neil Young & Crazy Horse garage rock song, and I can't get enough of that technically very simple but great sounding one-note guitar solo.

 

[Phil B.]

These two songs are quite equal in my eyes (as far as the "classic" status goes), but I agree with Jonny Come Lately.

CG's guitar is massive, and the fuzzed outro bit remains a watermark for me in my listening history.

 

[Jet]

Brown Eyed Girl

 

[Lady Stardust]

Brown eyed girl has always been the song I dedicate to myself, and now to my daughter. I love Cinnamon Girl, but sentimentality wins out in this case

-Diana

 

[Roxi]

I could be happy the rest of my life with a Cinnamon Girl.

 

[JerseyGirl]

Brown Eyed Girl

 

[Rocking Jodi]

Cinnamon Girl