Then He Kissed Me vs Then I Kissed Her

[ILoveJimmyPage]

Going way old school on this one. Which do you prefer?

Then He Kissed Me ~ The Crystals


vs.

Then I Kissed Her ~ The Beach Boys

 

[runningshoes]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

I get a sick feeling in my gut from anything Phil Spector had his hands on but I have to go with the original.

 

[METALPRIEST]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

The Crystals

 

[Hydrazoic Acid]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

I like KISS version more. Seriously, vote for Beach Boys.

 

[WetWilly]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

Beach Boys

 

[ILoveJimmyPage]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

I voted for The Crystals

 

[gcczep]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

It was a Crystals clear choice for me.

 

[LG]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

Beach Boys easily for me.

 

[Lynch]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

Definitely like this version the best:

(can't believe that you being the big KISS
fan that you are, missed this one (shameful))

 

[Lynch]

Re: Then He Kissed Me vs. Then I Kissed Her

As for the two versions in the poll, I like both for different reasons. The Crystals version is part of the soundtrack of my life seeing as it's played in a scene in the movie Goodfellas (when Karen and Henry are going into that club through the back), so I always think of that movie and that scene when I hear the Crystals.

I do have to say that I like the Beach Boys version just a little bit better though. I'm not a very big Beach Boys fan, but I think this was one of their better moments. (yeah yeah, shaddap with your Pet Sounds album)