^^^ Your love for pop music makes me smile.
I've always been a firm believer in variety being the spice of life. I think rock will always be my genre of choice but the first EVER genre I appreciated was pop, and my music tastes seem to stem from that early influence. Even when it comes to rock, Zeppelin (and the occasional Sabbath on rare occasions) is about as "heavy" as I go. I enjoy pop music. It's a fun genre and not meant to be taken too seriously IMO. If I want to shake it to some Katy Perry then light a doobie (not really) to some Kashmir, I'll do it!
Rebecca's music is meant to be just that: fun and carefree. I don't know why these kids take it so seriously that they felt the need to taunt her. Jealousy, methinks.
Besides, if they think she's bad apparently they haven't given Jan Terri (a.k.a. my IDOL!) a good listen.
Rock is my favorite genre by about a thousand leaps and bounds, but I see it manifest itself in all kinds of different ways. More than anything I judge music by how it makes me feel... Like when I got into Burzum it felt to me more like Nirvana than STP or AIC or Mudhoney or Flipper ever could, with its bare bar chords, simplistic arrangements, and unbridled rage. It had that purity, simplicity to it that no one else had.
I see so much more of my all-time favorite artists like Neil Young, Bob Dylan and Tom Petty... inside the music of Taylor Swift, Paramore, and Ke$ha than in any of those indie rock bands, who all seem to be spending as much time on
Arc as they do on
Harvest. In my mind rock music is
supposed to have big choruses, universal lyrics, and straight-forward song structures. Different takes on the same concept is how I see it....
In other words I'd get bored listening to 15 different thrash metal bands, but a few thrash, some groove, some black-thrash, some death.... and you're keeping my interest, lol. I love what you said about Katy & Kashmir, because that's exactly how I think, as well. It would make no better sense to listen to Ke$ha while you're trying to brood and reminisce on dark memories, than it does to listen to Revolution 9 when you're trying to dance. Different styles lend themselves to different moods and uses...
I also like what you said about Sabbath being as heavy as you go... Because yeah I listen to extreme metal, but I'm starting to realize that I've
always been a pop guy at heart. I never knew why I could never get fully invested in indie rock or noise or death metal, etc, I mean I like them but it was never a know-every-song-by-heart kind of thing like I am with Neil or Floyd or Nirvana... Then when I got into pop music it all came together and made sense. The thing that those experimental bands lack, and my favorite rock bands exhibit, are simple straight-forward lyrics and big, fat, juicy pop choruses. Neil Young, Bob Dylan, The Doors, Alice In Chains, even Pink Floyd is full of 'em.
Classic rock is my favorite because it blends the artsy aspects with the full on pop beef. If another band were to come out that was like that, with 10 three-minute pop/rock songs and 2 ten minute experimental freakouts per album like a classic band... I would love the shit out of them, they'd be my favorite band. But until that happens, I'm'a sit here twiddling my thumbs and noticing how Taylor Swift exhibits probably 90% of what I love about Bob Dylan. Lush organic instrumentations, stark honest vocals that are more emotional than they are technically apt, intelligent true to life lyrics and straight forward verse-chorus-verse song structures. I've always been more about Tangled Up In Blue and It Ain't Me Babe, than Desolation Row and Visions of Johanna.
Sorry for the long post! I just felt my unadulterated love for pop deserved a proper frame of reference... Or else I just wanted to talk about pop for a good while.