Mistral Wind
Senior Member
nice song, I like it, musically, but melodically it doesn't give me much... 6,5/10
Rate The Song Above You Part III
- Thread starter Riff Raff
- Start date
Hydrazoic Acid
Cynic
I like the instrumental and the whole gloomy mood, but it could be a couple of minutes shorter. 7/10.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Mistral Wind
Senior Member
he has a beautiful voice, but I think that the song is musically flat... 5/10
Hydrazoic Acid
Cynic
Really cool song from psychedelic era. Very catchy chorus and guitars. Closer to hard-rock, than to "flower music". Add to my playlist. Thank you, Giuseppe. 
8.5/10.
8.5/10.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
BeatleMatt
Senior Member
I went with a friend to Seether in concert once. Meh. And I did not enjoy this song either. 3/10
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Mistral Wind
Senior Member
well, not particularly brilliant, but not even bad. One can listen to it without skipping it.
And if you, as a musician, can obtain that at least, it's already a good thing. 6/10
@Sergey: glad you enjoyed that song, man!
And if you, as a musician, can obtain that at least, it's already a good thing. 6/10
@Sergey: glad you enjoyed that song, man!
Hydrazoic Acid
Cynic
@Sergey: glad you enjoyed that song, man!
"Thumbelina" is a very positive sounding song. It jives, I like it. 7.5/10.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Mistral Wind
Senior Member
honestly, it's pretty pleasant... good instrumentals, and well sung. I don't understand why they are one of the most hated rock band in history... (I read it somewhere, years ago). This is a good song. 7,5/10
Hydrazoic Acid
Cynic
You know, Giuseppe, I attribute this to a very competent marketing and a great commercial success of the band. Remember Kiss - they have a huge army of fans, and a crowd of haters - at the same time. Successful artists who are obviously "sharpened" for the release of a commercially successful product and don't hide their motivation and intentions - a very tempting target for attacks.
"Telescope": very aggressive sludge with totally distorted guitars. Cool. 7/10.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Mistral Wind
Senior Member
well, this song is good musically, and the melody becomes catchier the more that you listen to it. 7,5/10
