I never bought a Genesis album after 'Duke' - and I didn't like that much either. They then for me ceased to be a rock band and became a pop group...I've nothing against 'pop' groups, like quite a lot of them, but my expectations of Genesis was much higher than for most other 70's bands after all the classic albums they made. Peter Gabriel continues to be so much more interesting musically than they did, plus they came across to me like Phil Collins's backing band after that, and he really turned into a soul singer, so it all got a bit weird for me. But everything up to 'Duke' was fan bloody tastic!