Prime
Daydreaming
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2010
- Posts
- 10,852
- Reaction score
- 67
Dream Theater (Official Thread)
- Thread starter JethroZepFloyd
- Start date
METALPRIEST
Senior Member
I know for a fact I am now....Best Buy has it on sale along with Cooper...grabbin' both! 
Cosmic Harmony
Senior Member
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2009
- Posts
- 12,935
- Reaction score
- 25
Excellent. Then I'm going to get both too then. 
METALPRIEST
Senior Member
Yeah big day for us...listening to Cooper still now...and I do have my Dream Theater. Will spin it in a bit here.
Prime
Daydreaming
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2010
- Posts
- 10,852
- Reaction score
- 67
Yeah big day for us...listening to Cooper still now...and I do have my Dream Theater. Will spin it in a bit here.
You're going to enjoy it. First time through was pretty enjoyable for me personally. It got better as I listened to it more.
METALPRIEST
Senior Member
Sweeeeet...pretty soon here
I've read comparisons to Images And Words. I don't hear that all. Comparison's to Scenes From A Memory. Somewhat in that DT has incorporated more of thier tear drop, lush pompous prog since Scenes. ADTOE doesn't come close to Scenes IMO. Not the heart and soul felt on Scenes.
This album sounds like a split between thier previous three albums and Scenes/Six Degrees. Really, nothing new. It's DT. Of course the musicianship is excellent although some parts the complexity is overbearing. Petrucci riffs are fantastic but at times wander off to wankery. The keys don't work on the prog-metal tracks with the heavy guitar riffs with the synthetic Styx like sound. A heavy handed Hammond would be much more suited IMO.
Where's the drums? Mangini has been smothered. Maybe Portnoy had some type of clause in his contract that his replacement be irrelevent.
DT has to be one of the most polarizing bands in metal. Definitely in prog-metal. Love 'em or hate 'em. I'm neither. I consider myself a centrist.
Maybe DT will do something different next album. It's becoming tiresome. Take a risk, like Opeth. If someone wants to hear something refreshing in prog-metal, check out Leprous' last two releases, 'Tall Poppy Syndrome' and 'Bilateral' from this year.
This album sounds like a split between thier previous three albums and Scenes/Six Degrees. Really, nothing new. It's DT. Of course the musicianship is excellent although some parts the complexity is overbearing. Petrucci riffs are fantastic but at times wander off to wankery. The keys don't work on the prog-metal tracks with the heavy guitar riffs with the synthetic Styx like sound. A heavy handed Hammond would be much more suited IMO.
Where's the drums? Mangini has been smothered. Maybe Portnoy had some type of clause in his contract that his replacement be irrelevent.
DT has to be one of the most polarizing bands in metal. Definitely in prog-metal. Love 'em or hate 'em. I'm neither. I consider myself a centrist.
Maybe DT will do something different next album. It's becoming tiresome. Take a risk, like Opeth. If someone wants to hear something refreshing in prog-metal, check out Leprous' last two releases, 'Tall Poppy Syndrome' and 'Bilateral' from this year.
METALPRIEST
Senior Member
So I can put my two cents in now. I love it...it's really good. Everything I expected and more.
But I do agree about the drums...they are played very well and too quiet when compared to other DT albums. So either it's to not show up Portnoy or Portnoy always made them louder for himself when he was in the band...and the new Mike is just goin' with the flow.
There is alot of great double bass work that could have been up more to be more punchy. But otherwise it's a great CD!!
But I do agree about the drums...they are played very well and too quiet when compared to other DT albums. So either it's to not show up Portnoy or Portnoy always made them louder for himself when he was in the band...and the new Mike is just goin' with the flow.
There is alot of great double bass work that could have been up more to be more punchy. But otherwise it's a great CD!!
I tell you what after my 3rd listen, Beneath the Surface, On the Backs of Angels are my 2 favourite songs, my favourite of the 10 plus minute affairs is Bridges in the Sky.
The various sounds in this album are just amazing, piano I hear in a lot of the songs too, some really good variety there. This album will get a video review from me when I am back home.
The various sounds in this album are just amazing, piano I hear in a lot of the songs too, some really good variety there. This album will get a video review from me when I am back home.
Similar threads
