I just got the latest version of Itunes so I don't have any plays but I can list my top 20 by using lastfm.
#1-"Calling Dr. Love"-KISS (60 plays)
#2-"I Was Made For Loving You"-KISS (57 plays)
#3-"Deuce"-KISS (53 plays)
#4-"Love Gun"-KISS (51 plays)
#5-"Lick It Up"-KISS (50 plays)
#6-"Hotter Than Hell"-KISS (50 plays)
#7-"Detroit Rock City"-KISS (49 plays)
#8-"Rock And Roll All Nite"-KISS (47 plays)
#9-"Heaven's On Fire"-KISS (47 plays)
#10-"Shout It Out Loud"-KISS (46 plays)
#11-"I Love It Loud"-KISS (44 plays)
#12-"Girl"-The Beatles (41 plays)
#13-"Black Diamond"-KISS (40 plays)
#14-"Forever"-KISS (40 plays)
#15-"Christine Sixteen"-KISS (37 plays)
#16-"With A Little Help From My Friends"-The Beatles (36 plays)
#17-"See You In My Dreams"-KISS (36 plays)
#18-"Drive My Car"-The Beatles (35 plays)
#19-"Love Me Do"-The Beatles (34 plays)
#20-"I'll Fight Hell To Hold You"-KISS (34 plays)