Songs You Would Change

Peter Norway

Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2011
Posts
85
Reaction score
0
First, any song where the vocalist doesn't know when to shut up.


U2 - "Love is Blindness": This is a beautiful song that fades out with a deeply felt instrumental coda, with Edge providing tasteful minimalist notes. Then Bono feels the need to insert himself again with some distracting vocal carping; as if he thought the rest of the band were up to something without him.


Zeppelin - "The Song Remains the Same": This would’ve made for a rollicking instrumental. Plant’s vocals are kewl in a crazed chipmunk sort of way, but distract from the pure musicality of the piece.


Queen - "Bohemian Rhapsody": Would have been better if Freddie and the mournful melodies that bookend the flamboyant mid-section were given more breathing room.


Def Leppard - "Pyromania": A near perfect album marred by fake drums and plastic harmonies. Reminds me of one of those tragic supermodels whose face gets slashed-up by some obsessed creep. In this case, a sanitized-sound obsessed creep named Mutt.


Journey - "Don't Stop Believing": Then you have songs that just don’t know when to quit. I'm sure this kind of repetitive ending is fun at concerts and camp fire sing-a-longs, but in less raucous environs it’s just annoying.


The Eagles - "Take It to the Limit": You can only become this boring by living in a constant haze of dope smoke. My memory could be wrong, but I swear as a kid I counted them repeating "take it to the limit" some 40 times. Hypnotically boring. At least Journey's excess doesn't put you to sleep.


Pink Floyd – "Echoes": The “wale” interlude was trippy in high school, but now sounds like something from a cheap sci-fi flick. Maybe that’s flippant. The passage is not without intrigue, but it could have been realized with a bit more subtlety.


U2 - "Pride (In the Name of Love)": Good song but the chorus crashes the party like a big drunk lunk. Everything is going swell, then Bono barges in with typical wide-mouth bluster. In the NAAAAYYYYMMM uvvvvv LUUUHHVVVVV!!! Most times rock singers can yell and sound like—well, cool rock stars yelling. But sometimes they just sound like you and me, in the shower, drunk.


Dio – "Holy Diver": That doomy synthesizer intro drones on for more than a minute, (seems like 10), serving as a buzz-kill to any aggression you’ve built up. A serious error in metal judgment. It may scare kids at a Chucky Cheese Halloween party, but it just makes me drowsy.


Stereolab – "Cybele’s Reverie": A wonderfully fluid pop song interrupted by blatant artistic pretention in the form of a fractious fiddle and repetitive vocals. Arty bands often feel the need to abrade an otherwise seamless melody so as to protect their art-house cred. As if creating a pure pop song would reduce them to common mallrat status.


Prince - "Raspberry Beret": Any Prince or Michael Jackson song where they throw in those pervy squeels. eeeeeeeYOOOOHHH!!! Really? it's sexy to sound like a little boy getting his balls smashed? If I made that noise in front of a woman she’d call the cops.
 

TheWhalerfan

Lovus My Avatarus
Joined
May 1, 2011
Posts
2,684
Reaction score
30
Location
Saskatchewan, Canada
Rush - "Roll the Bones". The music I like, but the lyrics and rap section in the middle just sound bad.

Rush - "Caravan". Awesome song, but a different chorus than "I can't stop thinking big" wouldn't hurt my feelings at all. Minor complaint though.

Rush - "Natural Science" - The first 4 minutes or so are great, then it just shifts gears and becomes too long. There is a synth break in the song and it should have ended at that point.

Heart - "Rockin' Heaven Down" - Great music, but lyrics could be better and needs another verse.

Heart - "If Looks Could Kill" - Music and lyrics are good, but need more guitar, less keyboards, and be played faster. The way they played it live in later concerts was perfect. This song deserves to rock much harder than the album version.

Faith No More - "The Real Thing" album. Songs are good, music also good, but Patton's voice was very whiny, unlike their later albums. Redo the vocals and I am a happy camper.
 

Riff Raff

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2010
Posts
20,958
Reaction score
11,089
Location
No
I would remove the empty middle section out of Zeppelins Whole Lotta Love, good song but that bit was not necessary.
 

Peter Norway

Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2011
Posts
85
Reaction score
0
Many of The Beatles songs of their mature period ended too soon. Especially Lennon led songs such as "I'm Only Sleeping", "Glass Onion", and "Being for the Benefit of Mr.Kite". "And Your Bird Can Sing" is given a choke hold after only 2 minutes.

Or maybe these songs are so damned good that it's just painful to accept them ending at all. Really, if they'd wanted to, they might've been a better Pink Floyd than Pink Floyd. Some of the trippier Lennon songs could have really opened up and taken flight instead of halting.
 

bells

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Posts
68
Reaction score
1
Journey - "Don't Stop Believing": Then you have songs that just don’t know when to quit. I'm sure this kind of repetitive ending is fun at concerts and camp fire sing-a-longs, but in less raucous environs it’s just annoying.

Did you mean "Lovin' Touchin' Squeezin'"? I don't remember singalong with "Don't Stop Believin'", but LTS has 28 bars (I counted) of naa-naa-naa-naa-naa. Over a minute & a half of na nas! I admit, I like the na nas.

I always wanted that last 10-15 second track from Van Halen's "Women & Children First" album to be made into a song. It's unnamed on the album, and does a slow, fabulous fade out. However, I just learned that on the CD it's called "Growth" and it ends suddenly with a thunk (not good, not the same). Anyway, the fade-out version is a great end to that album, and it's probably perfect as is, but I remember always wanting more of it; wondering what it would have been.
 
Last edited:

Peter Norway

Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2011
Posts
85
Reaction score
0
Did you mean "Lovin' Touchin' Squeezin'"? I don't remember singalong with "Don't Stop Believin'", but LTS has 28 bars (I counted) of naa-naa-naa-naa-naa. Over a minute & a half of na nas! I admit, I like the na nas.

Holy crap that IS what I meant.
 

Find member

Forum statistics

Threads
31,574
Posts
1,126,100
Members
6,628
Latest member
Buckeye Randy

Members online

Top