Quad or Graffiti or The Wall?

[Texas King]

Your pick between these 3 double albums?
Quad for me.

 

[That 70s Guy]

The Wall

 

[SanguineRemedy]

While Pink Floyd is my favorite band of all time, The Wall is actually one of my least favorite albums but it's still an excellent album, nonetheless. Roger Water's dominance over the album seems to undo my feel for the music.

Led Zeppelin is opposing outgunned here, by my personal tastes. Stiiilll, Physical Graffiti is one of the band's best...

... but Quadrophenia is my favorite Who album. My choice.

All three will transcend time, though.

 

[Speed King]

I can decide between The Wall and Physical Graffiti,.....

 

[CRAZY-HORSE]

I can decide between The Wall and Physical Graffiti,.....

I'm with you on this one mate

 

[CRAZY-HORSE]

While Pink Floyd is my favorite band of all time, The Wall is actually one of my least favorite albums but it's still an excellent album, nonetheless. Roger Water's dominance over the album seems to undo my feel for the music.

Led Zeppelin is opposing outgunned here, by my personal tastes. Stiiilll, Physical Graffiti is one of the band's best...

... but Quadrophenia is my favorite Who album. My choice.

All three will transcend time, though.

The Division Bell is my favourite PF album followed by The Final Cut...
Not too keen on Waters solo material, I find it very patchy at best...
Love Gilmour's solo material, Rattle That Lock is my fave of his.

 

[Riff Raff]

Tough between The Who and LZ as they're the only ones I like on the poll but LZ one gets my vote. Best double LP I've heard.

 

[Magic]

No doubt.....Physical Graffiti. Kashmir is a beast! Add Ten Years Gone, In The Light, Houses of the Holy, and In My Time of Dying.......quadrophenia nor the wall can compete.......


Great poll @Texas King

 

[Vader]

Zeppelin.

 

[joker1961]

I can decide between The Wall and Physical Graffiti,.....

I'm with you on this one mate

which sick twisted mind thought of putting these three awesome album together in a poll!!!! well all three could get my vote on any given day! but like @Speed King/@CRAZY-HORSE. . .cannot chose between The Wall and Physical Graffiti.............brain meltdown