Physical Graffiti vs The Wall

[electric funeral]

Hard to choose, love both...................

 

[Sharp Dressed Man]

Physical Graffiti

 

[architect]

The Wall

 

[Khor1255]

Physical Graffiti by a mile.

 

[George]

Physical Graffiti easily!

 

[Hurdy Gurdy Man]

Wow!Quite the epic battle here.I'm giving the nod to "Graffiti" just because I feel ITS quality pans out a bit more than the Floyd effort's does."Wall" for me is really strong for a good while,but somehow in my mind,it drifts into near obscurity levels of conceptual overkill.I think the double vinyl set should have been released in condensed single disc form,just as some might argue about the Beatles' "White Album"..........

 

[Magic]

Physical Graffiti

 

[Mr. Bob Dobolina]

I love them both, but I had to go with "The Wall". I can cherry pick with "Physical Graffiti", but I have to listen to "The Wall" all the way through.

 

[CLASIKROKR]

Both good, but The Wall - Pink Floyd has more songs that I like!!

 

[Dan]

I'd like to echo what a lot of people are saying. The wall isn't one of the floyds best. But truthfully Pink Floyds main virtue is their ability to make ALBUMS that you just have to listen to the whole thing. Song(WALL) vs song(PG) then ZEP wins, but ALBUM vs ALBUM then Pink Floyd are undeniable gods. So the wall wins easily.