I guess I used to be a fan boy. KISS could no wrong in the eyes of this 14 year old.
Years down the road now, I'm not under any delusion that KISS is the greatest band of all time
Their songs are pretty basic, music wise. Although I will say this: Gene Simmons is a far better bassist than he's given credit for.
KISS never wrote any 'deep' stuff, musically or lyrically. 90% of their songs are about getting the girl, losing the girl, using the girl, longing for the girl, etc, etc.
How ever, they more than made up for those shortcomings with their shows. I've seen them 7 times (once w/o makeup), and I'm hear to tell ya, I never walked away feeling like been robbed. There's so much at their shows, you couldn't watch it at all once. They put on one heck of a show.
For all their hyperbole about their own greatness, I'll give them credit for one thing:
They never, ever shortchanged their fans. They spared no expence for their shows.
If a non-fan went to one, I don't think they'd become a rabid, hardcore fan, but I'm pretty sure they'd appreciate KISS a little more.