Kashmir vs Comfortably Numb

[That 70s Guy]

Comfortably Numb

 

[TheSound]

This is a cruel poll, nobody should be forced to chose between two such sublime classics, but I'll vote for Kashmir on the basis that Zeppelin never bettered it, whereas Floyd I thought did some superior stuff to Comfortably Numb...if you ever do a poll for best guitar solo of all time though, Gilmour on 'Numb' would probably get my vote.

 

[Hydrazoic Acid]

"Kashmir" is great, but I like "Comfortably Numb" a bit more.

 

[LG]

I agree with North Pink Floyd in this one.

 

[Magic]

very difficult to choose.....but my vote goes to the Mighty Led Zeppelin with Kashmir

 

[Vehicle]

I just put Floyd ahead 11~10

 

[Kuaizi]

Comfortably Numb for me!

 

[Big Ears]

Comfortably Numb by Pink Floyd. Kashmir is extremely influential, you can even hear it in Deep Purple's Perfect Strangers, but I can never really get into Led Zeppelin. Having said that, Comfortably Numb is not Pink Floyd's best track (I found The Wall disappointing), it just has a great solo from David Gilmour.

 

[ILoveJimmyPage]

Of course I voted for Kashmir, but Comfortably Numb isn't too far behind. You can get completely lost in both songs.

 

[Tangerine]

This is a cruel poll, nobody should be forced to chose between two such sublime classics, but I'll vote for Kashmir on the basis that Zeppelin never bettered it, whereas Floyd I thought did some superior stuff to Comfortably Numb...if you ever do a poll for best guitar solo of all time though, Gilmour on 'Numb' would probably get my vote.

That is exactly why I vote for Kashmir. It's my favorite Zeppelin song and probably their best. I love Comfortably Numb, and the solo it's amazing, but I think Floyd did better songs (and it's not even my fav from The Wall). Amazing anyway...
Good thing is this is just a poll and we can listen to both