Finale De Floyd

[architect]

Although I'm not completely thrilled with any of them, The Division Bell is the most coherent and listenable.

 

[Mr. Bob Dobolina]

The Final Cut

 

[Cosmic Harmony]

And last the Final Cut, but Cosmic you have got me to play FC more because of our chat in the PF thread so it's moved up a few slots on my overall seeding.

Well that's all I could ask for.

I don't think it's a surprise which I voted for.

 

[ILoveJimmyPage]

The Division Bell

 

[Masherbrum]

No Rick Wright kills The Final Cut for me. Kamen was good, but it isn't the same and that is what sticks out the most.

The Division Bell is my favorite of the the three listed, because they were "a band again" (not many session musicians) and it showed in the music. IMO, they recorded it with the sole intent of going back to the WYWH years and a democratic type of recording.

 

[LG]

^^You make some good points, however one reason I picked AMLOR is because of "The Delicate Sound of Thunder" VHS tape I bought in the early 90's, i thoroughly enjoyed the concert and picked up AMLOR after I got the video.

 

[Mr. Shadow]

 

[Masherbrum]

^^You make some good points, however one reason I picked AMLOR is because of "The Delicate Sound of Thunder" VHS tape I bought in the early 90's, i thoroughly enjoyed the concert and picked up AMLOR after I got the video.

Oh trust me, out of the three bro, ALLOT is miles ahead of the final cut and right on the heels of TDB. I merely went on a "gun to the head and pick one".

Imo, DSOT is one of the best live albums. Only a couple of things were touched and for the most part, it was spot on with what I heard live in Auburn Hills a mere week prior to that MSG show being recorded. It is raw and I like it more than PULSE.

 

[LG]

Imo, DSOT is one of the best live albums. Only a couple of things were touched and for the most part, it was spot on with what I heard live in Auburn Hills a mere week prior to that MSG show being recorded. It is raw and I like it more than PULSE.

I'm glad I have some company an old friend of mine always goes on and on about how much better Pulse is than "Delicate..." I mean they are both great but I will always enjoy DSOT more, and yeah even on VHS because I've never seen it on DVD.

 

[Lynch]

In order:

Momentary Lapse of Reason
Division Bell
The Final Cut


Division Bell is REALLY close behind Lapse. Final cut is a LONG way off in third place.