^^^ I agree about Alright Now, I used to love it and now it pretty much washes over me cos I've heard it so much over the years.
From the list I'd pick Don't Sop Believin' especially since The X-Factor made it hugely popular again over here a few years back, although it's not so much the radio that keeps banging it on but just that everywhere you go, from weddings to background music in shops, there it is rearing its ugly head.
I do think what's overplayed here in UK can differ quite a bit to which songs by the same band are overplayed over The Pond - I hear Zeppelin's Whole Lotta Love and Communication Breakdown more than any others.
Anyone that knows me knows how much I love Metallica, but I sure wish they would stop playing Enter Sandman so much, talk about major overkill.
As for voting in the poll I'm going to go with 'Other', having Sweat Child o' Mine in mind - another song that has been played to absolute death by the radio, so much so I actually quite despise the thing now.