Better solo artist? Waters or Gilmour?

[billyporter]

i have one gilmour solo album and two waters albums, so i guess roger is the best!

 

[LG]

Going by volume Roger would get the nod...but I like David's first solo album and his last one more than anything Roger has done. Roger's solo works are so dark and gloomy I have trouble staying interested.

Also unlike Khor, I Like PF without Roger just fine.

 

[METALPRIEST]

Roger Waters

I just love his stuff

 

[KingHeadache]

Roger Waters

 

[b.o.b.]

Roger Waters

 

[Big Ears]

Gilmour, because I don't like Roger Waters. Richard Wright's Wet Dream is an excellent, but underrated, album. Gilmour and Wright's version of Echoes on Live in Gdansk is amazing.

 

[Lynch]

Really not very big on either one of their solo careers, however Gilmour does still have some outstanding guitar solos in his work and I really don't remember much of anything from Waters standing out, at least of the stuff I've heard.

 

[architect]

I like David's musicality better than Rog's politics.

 

[Magic]

Gilmour easily

 

[Tek_54]

David Gilmour