Abacab vs. 90125 vs. Discipline

[Aktivator]

I like all three albums but this isn't even close Discipline.

I was curious to see what Rate your music thought about it.

Discipline#11 for 1981 , #969 overall
Genesis-Abacab #638
Yes-90125-264 for 1983

I would take Genesis ABACAB over 90125 too

 

[Magic]

Abacaab with 90125 in second place.

 

[Gabble Ratchet]

Agreed! That's such a killer song, but with the title track, Me and Sarah Jane, No Reply At All, Like It or Not, etc it's a solid album.

@ Groovy Man - I agree 90125 is a brilliant album, I just like Abacab a little bit more

You just listed my all my favourite songs from Abacab! (Including Dodo/Lurker of course)

It also gets my vote, though once again 90125 is a close second

 

[Abraxas]

Discipline

 

[runtfan]

Pretty close for me between all three. I gave 90125 my vote.

 

[b.o.b.]

90125

 

[Sox]

90125

 

[TrekkiELO]

Abacab

 

[Phil B.]

Yes: 90125

 

[runningshoes]

90125 easily for me.