Sep 18, 2017 #1 T Texas King Senior Member Joined Jun 26, 2016 Posts 633 Reaction score 126 I'm going with Genesis. Both songs have great guitar solos.
Sep 18, 2017 #2 Vader Veteran Of A Thousand Psychic Wars Joined Jul 3, 2014 Posts 10,721 Reaction score 17,849 Location Mother Gaia Floyd
Sep 18, 2017 #3 Frands Senior Member Joined Jun 17, 2017 Posts 7,315 Reaction score 13,752 Location Esbjerg, Denmark Pink Floyd
Sep 18, 2017 #4 That 70s Guy Super Moderator Staff member Super Moderator Joined Jan 21, 2010 Posts 18,211 Reaction score 10,274 Location Nova Scotia Canada Comfortably Numb
Sep 18, 2017 #5 SanguineRemedy Speed Demon Joined Oct 25, 2016 Posts 7,255 Reaction score 16,485 Location Mad Max Wasteland The Floyd!
Sep 18, 2017 #6 joe Senior Member Joined Jul 9, 2010 Posts 6,717 Reaction score 1,602 Location Cascadia Genesis
Sep 18, 2017 #7 bbif Senior Member Joined Jul 24, 2012 Posts 390 Reaction score 750 Location Australia Can see the rational behind wanting to compare these 2 classic songs, but really, it's no contest. As much as I absolutely adore almost everything Genesis, Comfy Numb is in a different league to FOF. And I LOVE FOF !
Can see the rational behind wanting to compare these 2 classic songs, but really, it's no contest. As much as I absolutely adore almost everything Genesis, Comfy Numb is in a different league to FOF. And I LOVE FOF !
Sep 18, 2017 #8 Speed King Rockin to the East & West Joined Feb 4, 2014 Posts 879 Reaction score 453 Location Back home, at Conry's Bar Pink Floyd.
Sep 18, 2017 #9 Magic Woman of the World Staff member Administrator Joined Apr 20, 2009 Posts 26,547 Reaction score 7,086 Location Ohio, USA I'm giving the nod to the grand piano!
Sep 19, 2017 #10 recgord27 Retired Joined Aug 8, 2013 Posts 10,133 Reaction score 15,916 Location Far away from the left wing Comfortably Numb - by a comfortable margin.