Bat Out Of Hell vs The Stranger

[TheWhalerfan]

Anything but Meat Loaf will get my vote

 

[LivingDead]

The Stranger, although it was a close one. I love Meat Loaf, but I think I love Billy just a tad bit more.

 

[LG]

Anything but Meat Loaf will get my vote

I kind of expected you to say that Whaler...

 

[Tommy Walker]

I do not feel that "The Stranger" is Billy's best album

Out of curiosity, what is? The Stranger is my favorite Billy Joel album by a long shot and a good bit better than Bat Out of Hell in my opinion too.

 

[Cosmic Harmony]

I think "52nd Street" is Billy's best album. It has all the jazzyness that "The Stranger" does but it incorporates other styles more and doesn't have the mushiness of "Just The Way You Are" and "She's Always a Woman" to slow it down. It's not uncommon for me to skip those songs when I listen to "The Stranger".

 

[Sunny]

Bat Out Of Hell but it was close

 

[architect]

The Stranger

 

[Riff Raff]

Bat Out Of Hell.

 

[CrazyConnie]

Bat Out Of Hell

 

[sco703]

The Stranger hands down. Such a fantastic album.