Arlo Guthrie vs. Don McLean

[joker1961]

American Pie, easily.

But I do like both.

ooh yes dude my vote too!

 

[OldHippie]

City of New Orleans

 

[Lynch]

Cant stand American Pie. 8.5 minutes that is about 5.5 minutes too long.

Definitely City of New Orleans

 

[Neshabur]

American Pie

 

[Dave78]

Cant stand American Pie. 8.5 minutes that is about 5.5 minutes too long.

Definitely City of New Orleans

 

[CrazyConnie]

City of New Orleans

 

[Schmetterling]

Always hated American Pie and don't know the other song so can't comment....