All My Love VS All My Loving

[rollingstoned]

Beatles leading with a score of 5-3.

 

[Lynch]

I know zeppelin gets a bit of grief for most of that In Through the Out Door album, but I personally like it. It shows how they transformed a bit during the decade. I do like All My Love.... but I can't vote against the Beatles here. All My Loving gets my vote.

 

[Syd]

Beatles!

 

[The Beatles]

Weird of me to vote against The Beatles, but I'm going with Led Zeppelin here, one of my favorite songs by them, against a painstakingly average (by beatles standards) tune.

 

[Nololob]

Everything beats Beatles. I vote for All My Love.

 

[The Beatles]

Everything beats Beatles. I vote for All My Love.

well somebody's ignorant.

 

[hawk11]

All My Loving

 

[R. Evans]

Led Zeppelin

 

[LG]

I like In Through The Out Door a lot more now than when it came out...and that Zep tune is good, but I'll take the Beatles in this one.

 

[Magic]

Led for the head.