"A Day In The Life" tops Rolling Stone magazine's Top 100 Beatles Songs

BeatlesFan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2010
Posts
960
Reaction score
0
Location
Toronto, Canada
Posted 8/23/2010 4:45:00 PM ROLLING STONE RELEASES “THE BEATLES 100 GREATEST SONGS”

“A Day in the Life” tops the list, as chosen by Rolling Stone editors

New York, NY – Rolling Stone released their first-ever list of the 100 greatest Beatles songs as part of a special interest publication that coincides with the 40th anniversary of the Beatles’ final album, Let It Be, and the 30th anniversary of John Lennon’s death. Topping the list, as ranked by the editors of Rolling Stone, is “A Day in the Life,” followed by “I Want to Hold Your Hand” and “Strawberry Fields Forever.”

Following an introduction by Elvis Costello, the book features the stories behind each song, dozens of photos, an index of the complete list, and a breakdown of the numbers, including the years with the most songs (1965 and 1966 each had 17), the shortest song (“Her Majesty,” 23 seconds) and the song that spent the longest time at number one on the charts (“Hey Jude,” 9 weeks).

The book also includes special sections with lists of Lennon and Paul McCartney’s five favorite songs, the top guitar and drumming moments of George Harrison and Ringo Starr, respectively, and the best Beatles cover songs.

Rolling Stone has been the leading voice of music and popular culture since its inception over 40 years ago. The magazine features the latest in music reviews, in-depth interviews, hard-hitting political commentary and award-winning investigative journalism. Rolling Stone provides all the news that fits to 13 million readers every two weeks.

Top 10 Greatest Beatles Songs

1. “A Day in the Life”
2. “I Want to Hold Your Hand”
3. “Strawberry Fields Forever”
4. “Yesterday”
5. “In My Life”
6. “Something”
7. “Hey Jude”
8. “Let It Be”
9. “Come Together”
10. “While My Guitar Gently Weeps"


Source: ROLLING STONE RELEASES "THE BEATLES 100 GREATEST SONGS" - Weekends Blog | 93.3 WMMR: Everything That Rocks

I agree with the choice of "A Day In The Life" as #1. :)
But I disagree with the rest. Strawberry Fields Forever should be #2, and I Want To Hold Your Hand shouldn't even be in the Top 10.
 
Last edited:

Foxhound

retired
Joined
Sep 22, 2009
Posts
3,584
Reaction score
8
Location
Toronto, Canada
Beatlesfan said:
I agree with the choice of "A Day In The Life" as #1.
But I disagree with the rest. Strawberry Fields Forever should be #2, and I Want To Hold Your Hand shouldn't even be in the Top 10.

I strongly and entirely disagree. "I Want to Hold Your Hand" was the Beatles' biggest hit in the early onslaught that not only made them rock icons but launched the British Invasion. It was these hits that changed the history of rock. Don't underestimate their importance. There should therefore be at least three more from this list in the top ten:

Please Please Me
She Loves You
I Saw Her Standing There
Day Tripper
A Hard Day's Night
Ticket to Ride
Help

"A Day in the Life" really didn't do anything to change the history of rock. The seeds of the Beatles' experimental psychedelic phase had already been sown in "Revolver" and had already hit full bloom with the release of the "Strawberry Fields Forever"/"Penny Lane" single.

:drums:
 

Death on Credit

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Posts
1,315
Reaction score
5
Location
Portland, OR
I actually pretty much agree with everything on that list.

'I Want to Hold Your Hand' might not necessarily be a great song, but, as Foxhound said, it's culturally significant.
 

SchindlerHaughton

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2010
Posts
259
Reaction score
0
Location
East Northport, NY
"I Want To Hold Your Hand" should be bumped off the list altogether if we're talking about quality of music. Replace it with "Golden Slumbers," "Carry That Weight," and "The End" (multiple parts to the same song). Everything else should remain on the list, although I might change some of the placement.
 
Last edited:

Foxhound

retired
Joined
Sep 22, 2009
Posts
3,584
Reaction score
8
Location
Toronto, Canada
"I Want To Hold Your Hand" should be bumped off the list altogether if we're talking about quality of music. Replace it with "Golden Slumbers," "Carry That Weight," and "Thank You" (multiple parts to the same song). Everything else should remain on the list, although I might change some of the placement.

If you're talking "quality", why then are you ignoring the salient detail that "I Want to Hold Your Hand" had more energy than the rest of the list combined? "Golden Slumbers" indeed!

:drums:

BTW, this thread actually should be in the 60's Rock Forum.

:pirate:
 

The Beatles

retired
Joined
May 1, 2010
Posts
1,328
Reaction score
0
I strongly and entirely disagree. "I Want to Hold Your Hand" was the Beatles' biggest hit in the early onslaught that not only made them rock icons but launched the British Invasion. It was these hits that changed the history of rock. Don't underestimate their importance. There should therefore be at least three more from this list in the top ten:

Please Please Me
She Loves You
I Saw Her Standing There
Day Tripper
A Hard Day's Night
Ticket to Ride
Help

"A Day in the Life" really didn't do anything to change the history of rock. The seeds of the Beatles' experimental psychedelic phase had already been sown in "Revolver" and had already hit full bloom with the release of the "Strawberry Fields Forever"/"Penny Lane" single.

:drums:

Its not all about what changed the history of rock and whatnot. Sure, its some about that, which is why I Want To Hold Your Hand is even on the list, but you also have to take into account that A Day In The Life is a very good song. For example, as important as Please Please Me or She Loves You is, the truth is that they aren't very good songs (this is, of course, by Beatles standards.)

Though I do agree with I Saw Her Standing There. Its just about as important as I Want To Hold Your Hand, and a far better song.
 

The Beatles

retired
Joined
May 1, 2010
Posts
1,328
Reaction score
0
"I Want To Hold Your Hand" should be bumped off the list altogether if we're talking about quality of music. Replace it with "Golden Slumbers," "Carry That Weight," and "Thank You" (multiple parts to the same song). Everything else should remain on the list, although I might change some of the placement.

There is no Beatles song Called Thank You, and it definitely isn't in the abbey road medley.

I think you meant, Golden Slumbers/ Carry That Weigh/ The End which I agree should be on there, but not at Number 2.
 

Find member

Forum statistics

Threads
30,724
Posts
1,068,803
Members
6,367
Latest member
allmylife11

Staff online

Members online

Top