Compile a 'Best of . . . ' for your favourite band

Jonny Come Lately said:

Cool, I was planning to start a thread along these lines but since there's already one I might as well post my ideas here:

Best Of Pink Floyd (1970-80)
1. In The Flesh? (3:18) (The Wall, 1979)
2. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) (13:33) (Wish You Were Here, 1975)
3. Time/Breathe (Reprise) (6:53) (The Dark Side Of The Moon, 1973)
4. Another Brick In The Wall (Part 2) (3:58) (The Wall, 1979)
5. Pigs On The Wing (8-track version with Snowy White guitar solo) (3:25) (Animals, 1977)
6. Comfortably Numb (6:22) (The Wall, 1979)
7. Money (6:23) (The Dark Side Of The Moon, 1973)
8. Us And Them (7:49) (The Dark Side Of The Moon, 1973)
9. Run Like Hell (4:23) (The Wall, 1979) (why wasn't this on the Echoes compilation?!?)
10. Have A Cigar (5:08) (Wish You Were Here)
11. Wish You Were Here (5:33) (Wish You Were Here, 1975) (including the radio introduction)
12. One Of These Days (5:56) (Meddle, 1971)
13. Brain Damage (3:46) (The Dark Side Of The Moon, 1973)
14. Eclipse (2:13) (The Dark Side Of The Moon, 1973)

Overall this comes out at a running time of 78 minutes 40 seconds. I've tried to put this in the most logical order I can come up. If necessary time could be saved by removing the Breathe (Reprise), editing Shine On... or fading out Wish You Were Here or Another Brick In The Wall earlier.

I'll stick to the 1970s as I think Pink Floyd's music before and after this period doesn't mesh well with the songs from this era, the older music is stylistically too different, while The Final Cut and A Momentary Lapse of Reason are both solo albums in spirit (The Divison Bell isn't, but is out of place with the songs here which mostly have Waters lyrics).

Omissions:
- The three main tracks from Animals - Dogs, Pigs (Three Different Ones) and Sheep - I think these only really work in the context of the album.
- Echoes, if we're going on absolute quality this is one of their finest tracks, but it's too long to include on a single disc without having to make numerous other compromises, and an edited version just wouldn't be as good.
- Breathe, although I could be accommodated if judicious edits were made.
- Hey You, Mother, Welcome To The Machine and The Great Gig In The Sky, just wasn't enough time left to fit these in, I would have liked to though.
- The Happiest Days Of Our Lives, not really essential Pink Floyd and I think starting ABITW II with the scream would work okay.
- Anything from Atom Heart Mother or Obscured By Clouds. Nothing on these two is quite strong enough to justify being included ahead of the strongest tracks on the albums included. If this was a two CD version then Fat Old Sun or If from AHM would have a fair chance of making the cut though.

One slight tweak I'd make would be to include the heartbeat from Eclipse at the start of In The Flesh, while putting 'Isn't this where...' at the end of Eclipse to create a fully cyclic compilation.

Click to expand...