Arlo Guthrie vs. Don McLean

[Dave78]

Which song do you prefer over the other?

 

[Jake T]

American Pie

 

[Frands]

American Pie

 

[BikerDude]

City.
Although it wasn't written by Arlo Guthrie.

 

[SanguineRemedy]

American Pie, easily.

But I do like both.

 

[joe]

Arlo. Prefer "City of N.O." to "Alice's Restaurant". "American Pie" just seems to drag on.

 

[recgord27]

City of New Orleans

 

[Magic]

American Pie

 

[Sharp Dressed Man]

I'll take Arlo's version of "City of New Orleans" over "American Pie", but I prefer Willie Nelson's version of the song. It was written by Steve Goodman btw.

 

[Abraxas]

American Pie