Discussion in 'Progressive Rock' started by joe, Nov 26, 2010.
How would you rate this album.
I would rate this one 6.5 on Joe's rating scale...I can't give it great because I do like other Yes albums more than Topograhpic, but I also think it gets a lot of undeserved criticism from all corners.
(Very Good is my Official rating.)
We're pretty much bang on LG. I give it a 7. BTW, did you ever think about going into politics?
^^Only as a "Benevolent Dictactor" beloved by all his subjects Joe, I could get used to being omnipotent for a while...
LG, I would say that's the case right here at CRF.
I would rule with an iron fist. Riegn in supremacy and conquest.
^^..."The naked fist is the Only thing the masses understand"...
Quote from President Joe's famous inaugural speech from his palace....(The ruins can still be seen on the hilltop which was burned to the ground after the riots broke out that ended his reign...)
^^^I will rise again with the antichrist and the false prophet.
I'll give it a "good" vote...there are other albums I like better as well. It ain't no Fragile.
Now that album is EXCELLENT...IMO of course.
excellent one step down from Close to the edge, Fragile, Relayer, Going for the one.
Loving all the polls of late . Thanks pollsters .
I gave Topo' a 7. Sadly,like Genesis' The Lamb....,this album is too complex,and a little too self indulgent at times. This over shadows the quality of the muscianship on these albums IMHO .
Separate names with a comma.