Master of Puppets or Rust In Peace?

[SanguineRemedy]

Your opinion whether positive or not on Metallica is fine, I think just how it was said may have added Fuel pun intended.

Oh, yooou!

 

[Lynch]

For me, this is waaaay too easy. Master crushes Rust. Both albums among each band's best, but I can listen to Master all day long. Rust only ever so often and I couldn't play it on "repeat" like I could with MoP.

 

[Riff Raff]

Gonna add the non-remastered Rust in Peace is vastly superior to the remastered.

 

[Magic]

Master of Puppets.

 

[joker1961]

 

[Sharp Dressed Man]

Master of Puppets.

Love them both.

 

[E-Z]

I only heard Master of Puppets all the way through once many years ago and don't really remember it but Rust in Peace I have heard a couple of dozen times in the past and thought it was one of Megadeth's better albums but I won't vote because it wouldn't be fair to Metallica.

E-Z

 

[Trickster]

Megadeth

 

[Vader]

I like Metallica, they are almost orchestral in their early works, but I don't listen to them post-AJFA because I don't think their discography is that consistent with quality, unlike Mustaine's band.

I'm just giving Metallica fans shit, so don't mind me.

I respect Metallica, but think they are slightly overrated.

I love early Metallica but they are HIGHLY overrated. People act as though they are the alfa and the omega.

 

[Riff Raff]

I love early Metallica but they are HIGHLY overrated. People act as though they are the alfa and the omega.

I think the Big Four concept overall just adds to that overrated status because no way could any have been more deserving of that spot over bands like Overkill, Exodus, Testament, Heathen etc.