Close To The Edge vs Thick As A Brick

[Stout]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Hello lads and lassies; long time its been , hasn`t it? For me, it has to be Close To the edge, possibly the greatest prog album, IMO. Pefection personified and gorgeous to booth. All three tracks are oustanding, but 'And You and I bowls me over the most. The production is sterling, and if a track can do that close to 40 years later, it`s a testament to it`s vitality. and wouldn`t you believe before I logged I here, I was already listening to the album.

 

[Sox]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Two classics but Tull's TAAB is the one.

 

[Magic]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Close to the Edge. Wasn't it the titile song in off this album that created such havoc amongst band members, coming to a decision that they were taking the prog songs too far?

 

[Sunny]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Thick As A Brick

 

[Gabble Ratchet]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

As I said earlier, this one is just too tight for me to call D:

 

[Tek_54]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Thick As A brick

 

[zeppelin rocker]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Both great but I vote for Yes here

 

[Scotty Baboon]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Jethro Tull - Thick As A Brick as i'm not into Yes.

 

[runningshoes]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

Close To The Edge

 

[Chevelle]

Re: Close To The Edge vs. Thick As A Brick

I have several Yes LPs but I don't rate them as high as a lot of people do.
Jethro Tull is a band that has always had a high rating in my collection.