Soot and Stars
I AM SOOT!
I voted Seattle Four...Mostly because I love Nirvana and Seattle.
However, I think that the "Big Four" are a far more coherent group. Other than coming out at about the same time in about the same city, I don't really think that Nirvana, Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, or Soundgardern have much in common. I don't think I'd even put any of them in the same genre.
You can always bet that whichever choice has received the most air play in a given poll will win around here .... it's no brainer for any gambler
I agree with DOC and DKW, I think both sets had plenty of airplay but it's a matter of when more than how much. I'm sure I'm influenced by the Seattle four more because they played during the time when I was in my coming of age musically. Also, the level of Metal is different for everyone making groups the Seattle four more hard rock in a lot of ways and more accessible for people like me!
So yeah, the Seattle four for me!