Review Asia- Self Titled (1982) * 1/2

album review

Catfish

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2024
Posts
505
Reaction score
483
Location
Texas
Classic Rock Album of the Day Album- Asia- Asia (1982) * 1/2

Can you imagine my excitement in 1981, when I was reading about the formation of a band, a supergroup formed from pieces of Yes, King Crimson, and Emerson Lake and Palmer? Well, today I am deviating from the norm, and reviewing what I felt was a very substandard product, considering the talent involved. When this album hit the air waves, I was already sold. "Heat of the Moment" had been almost simuateaneously released, and for good reason. This was an great great song. Maybe the perfectly constructed hooked, power chorded rocker in an '80's era that had been flooded by new wave product.

So I obviously took the bait, and forked over my about $5.99 at the time, got it home, put it in the turntable, and was pissed. What resulted was a inverse sum of the parts of these bands... No heart, no soul, no songwriting prowess (minus Heat) Yeah, commercial glitz and corporate wizardry has wrestled this LP, even to No. 1 on the charts. This group and Damned Yankees has sullied the rock landscape with the term "Super Group". It didn't take long for the record buying public to catch on. This album hit no.1 The second one- No. rthe 3rd- 67, and then six albums that didn't even crack the Top 200. The fact that this band was allowed to make 13 studio albums is a mystery, except for the fact that many super fans are hell bent on having the collection of members of their former bands.

But yes, I was duped, loved the one song, and cursed Geffen and his traveling Snake Oil Business afterwards. I was also very disappointed at some of the legends that I hold in very very very high regard who took part in this debacle. This includes Carl Palmer, Steve Howe, and John Wetton.

Fun Fact: Asia went 23 years and 7 albums (CD's) later in a drought of commercial failures (top 200) 1985-2008. Seen a lot of discography and that is pretty unique in length and volume.

Songs-
-------------

Heat of the Moment- I will have to admit, that this one song is one of the best rock tunes of the early 1980's. Beaurtiiful power chorded, that has more hooks that at a quilting show. Which is part of the problem. Wetton almost sounds like Greg Lake in a vocal effort of a lifetime. Palmer's only inspired (at least for him) clicks and fills on the LP too. Seems they spent their entire studio time, sinking all their creative eggs in one basket. Fantastic song. 1

I wouldn't say the rest of the album is true filler. "Only Time Will Tell " is a decent representative of the band's cumulative talents. Otherwise, pretty much everything Asia made was ill conceived, and an inverse sum of the parts of the talent of the particpants. The era of the supergroups sucked, and did irreparable damage to the AOR genre. 2

Everything else- 3-9


 
Last edited:

dr wu

Dr Prog
Joined
Mar 18, 2020
Posts
3,514
Reaction score
4,489
Location
Indiana
I was also disappointed ...was hoping for more but the guys were looking for a payday.
;)
 

BeatleMatt

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2022
Posts
5,782
Reaction score
7,500
Location
In The Land Of Submarines
Over the weekend I made a playlist of good, first songs from debut albums and included “Heat of The Moment”. But I do agree, a great majority of their discography is talent wasted for some reason.
 

Ar-Pharazon

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2013
Posts
1,534
Reaction score
596
I feel like I benefitted from the fact I had no idea at the time what bands these guys were previously in.

I was hooked by the singles and it's still my favorite Asia album, with Alpha at #2.

I went on to own all the other albums at one time or another, including the Aurora EP on vinyl which I still have.

The later John Payne releases were a little more "prog", if I may use that term so late in the day ;)
 

Find member

Forum statistics

Threads
31,518
Posts
1,121,589
Members
6,617
Latest member
Testguy

Members online

No members online now.
Top