Tough to vote on this one, and not because the albums are similar. Get Your Wings has one of my top 2 favorite Aerosmith tracks in Train Kept-A-Rollin', which is hard to vote against. Same Old Song and Dance was the first Aerosmith song that I learned how to play on the guitar (at least intro and rhythm section). There's a nostalgia factor right there that is also hard to beat.
Rocka Rolla doesn't have a single stand-out song on it (for me) like this Aerosmith album has, but looking at it as a full body of work, it's a great, classic debut by JP that I grew to love over the years.
Band vs Band, Judas Priest wins every time.
Album vs Album - hard to say
Song vs Song - GYW has more heavy hitters on it.
*shrug*