Wrong Question, maybe ?
Many prefer one brand of guitar over another. Professionals like David Gilmour perform with many guitar brands. They chose the instrument for different reasons. Many like a Gibson acoustic guitar but use a Fender Stratocaster when going electric. Blues men like B.B.King chose yet another style. Some of the best own hundreds of guitars in different brands and styles.
I've seen shows where guitars were changed up to 8 times or more. They chose for quality of sound, color, shape, acoustic, electric, bass, 12 string, etc.
Some like a skinny neck, it's easier for them to play. Some have large hands and prefer a thick neck. The reason one brand is liked and another is not is as complex as the guitarist.
Perhaps a list of the all time best guitarist would be more appropriate .